Chapter 45: Truth or Dare - Lily, Angela, Susan, Josh, Ben, Bruce, Randy, Joey

Josh and Lily held hands as they met up with their friends Susan, Angela, Bruce, Randy and Ben outside the theatre. They were all 19 year old second year students

Lily was literally the prettiest girl on campus and at 5'8" with C cup breasts, she was everyone's dream girl.

Her friends Susan and Angela were very beautiful too and it was hard to say that they were inferior in any way to Lily.

As for the guys, the 6'1" tall and handsome Josh was the best looking guy on campus while Ben, Bruce and Randy were very good looking in their own right.

Besides Josh dating Lily, Ben and Susan together with Bruce and Angela were also dating each other. Randy came by himself but was known on campus to be a player with a non stop stream of girls fucked and dumped by him.

"....I heard this show is awesome" Randy was saying as the rest waved at Josh and Lily.

"You got the tickets?" Susan asked. "Right here" showed Josh as he fanned out the 7 tickets.

They sat next to each other in the front seats of the small theatre that fit only around 30 people.

The small crowd quietened down as the lights dimmed and the curtains suddenly raised.

"Ladies and Gentlemen, the Erotic Magician!" a beautiful voice sounded from the speakers.

"The Erotic Magician?" whispered Susan to Lily "Is this going to be a sex show?"

"I don't know. This is the first I've heard of it" answered Josh on Lily's behalf.

A beautiful brunette walked on stage, completely naked and stood in the middle of the stage

"Hi my name is Kelly and I'm not the Magician. I am merely the Magician’s assembler tonight" she said smiling.

"Assembler?" asked everyone to themselves.

Several other women came on stage, holding different body parts that seemed like some parts of a mannequin.

Theresa, a gorgeous blond assistant held what looked like a torso and gave it to Kelly to hold.

Amanda, a dark skinned assistant held what looked like a the bottom half of a torso and Kelly helped assemble the top torso to this bottom half.

Tyler, a brunette assistant brought out two arms and attached them to the torso that Kelly was holding.

Another brunette assistant Tara brought out two legs and similarly assembled them onto the mannequin that Kelly was holding.

The mannequin stood on it’s own now as Kelly stood behind it, waiting for the next part.

A gorgeous blonde named Heather came on stage holding a head which had a very handsome face and long hair and attached it to the mannequin.

Suddenly, the eyes opened and the face smiled as he moved. Kelly gestured at the Magician and started walking off stage.

"Wait a minute! There's still a missing piece" he smiled in an alluring voice

Kelly looked sheepish as she reached between her legs and extracted a 9 inch fully erect cock and kissed it’s head before attaching it on the Magician’s body.

The cock stood proudly erect on the stage, still glistening with Kelly’s pussy juices.

"That... that can't be real" said Lily astonished.

"It's very real indeed ma'am" the Magician said as he heard her. "Would you like to check? Please come on stage to help me verify this" he said as he invited her on stage.

Lily hesitated, but as the whole audience was clapping and her boyfriend Josh was nudging her, she stood up and went on stage.

"What’s your name? Who did you come with?" the Magician asked with a smile.

"Hi I'm Lily. I came with my boyfriend Josh, as well as my group of best friends Susan, Angela, Bruce, Randy and Ben" she answered as she waved at them.

"Well that gives me an easy time finding volunteers. Can all of you come up please" he smiled as the audience continued clapping.

They all looked at each other and hesitantly got up and walked on stage.

He shook all their hands and got their names, and got them to stand in a line behind himself and Lily.

"But first, I want you to verify that my penis is real. Can you do that?" he asked.

"Ho...how?" she stammered looking at his flaccid cock.

"Go ahead. Touch it, prod it, up to you. But make really sure" he said.

Lily looked at Josh who shrugged at her, so she bent over and took a closer look at his cock.

She slowly touched it. It felt really realistic. But she couldn't get the image of Kelly putting the Magician together like a mannequin out of her mind.

She started pulling and pumping the penis and suddenly gasped as the Magician made his penis twitch.

"Convinced now?" the Magician asked as his 9 inch penis pointed directly at her.

"No... I don't know" she said as she looked at the handsome man and his irresistible looking cock.

"Then what would it take to convince you?" he asked looking at her with a quizzical look.

"Well... you know...if it can errr perform" she said bravely, biting her lip adorably as she said it.

The whole audience was completely silent and Josh's jaw dropped. Susan and Angela stared at his cock the entire time thinking the same thing.

"You know what? I promise you before the show has ended, you will see this cock perform. Is that ok? I want to use your friends here on stage too" he said smiling

"Ok. You promised" she said challenging him, still looking at his cock.

"Alright. Which one of you is Josh, the boyfriend of Lily? Please come here and stand with her here" he asked.

Josh lifted his hand and stepped forwards and stood next to Lily.

Josh was a pretty good looking guy too, and everyone thought was a perfect match for Lily looks wise.

"How long have you guys been dating?" he asked them

"About a year now" he answered honestly.

"So I assume you know each other intimately? Have you had sex?" he continued asking.

Josh was stunned and could not respond and Lily only blushed as they both shook their heads.

"We're keeping ourselves pure for marriage" explained Josh. 

"Really? Virgins? I find that amazing! I’ll get back to you two later. How about the rest of you Are any of you dating each other?" he asked the others on stage.

“We’ve been dating for a month now” said Ben as he held Susan’s hands.

“Around two months for us” said Bruce as he held Angela’s hands.

“So I assume you know your partners intimately?” the Magician asked.

All 4 of them blushed and didn’t respond.

“What about you?” the Magician asked Randy who was by himself.

“Uh… I didn’t bring anyone” he smiled sheepishly.

“Don’t worry, we’ll find something for you tonight to make sure you're not left out” smiled the Magician.

"Ok right now I'm going to play a simple game with all of you. It's called Truth or Dare" he said "But you'll all be hypnotized" he added.

Before anyone could say anything, the Magician snapped his hands and everyone on stage with him suddenly stood still with a blank look on their faces.

"You won't move or talk unless ordered to by me. You will only be able to show emotions on your face" ordered the Magician.

“Now, since this is truth or dare, you will all be hypnotized to tell only the truth. You are all unable to lie, and you must always do the dares I place on you” he continued.

The volunteers stared blankly. They stood like mannequins with but their faces showed their expression of fear but yet anticipation..

“Now to get the answers I am looking for” the Magician smiled as he looked to Josh and Lily

“So are you guys really virgins?” he asked

Josh nodded but Lily shook her head.The Magician could see the shock on Josh’s face.

“Oh oh, I see a discrepancy. So Lily, Josh wasn't your first sexual experience?” he asked again

Lily shook her head. By now the audience was completely silent.

Although their bodies were immobile, their faces showed their emotions. Josh was surprised and looked angry, while Lily could only look away.

“So, is the lover here among you on stage?” asked the Magician

Lily nodded. Josh was shocked and angrily looked at his best friends Ben, Bruce and Randy.

"Without mentioning names, what happened Lily?" the Magician asked

"I got drunk during orientation and was having a good time with this person. The next thing I knew, I lost my virginity to him" she said, nearly as a whisper as she couldn't look Josh in his eyes.

"Did you only fuck him that one time?" the Magician asked.

"No, we fucked several times daily for a week, but I had to break up with him as my boyfriend Josh was arriving the next week" she said.

“You already had a boyfriend? What happened Lily?” the Magician asked

“Josh is my hometown sweetheart. We came from the same area, but different schools. But we met together in church and got together. We chose to remain chaste for each other” she answered.

“Then what happened?” asked the Magician

“Josh had a family funeral so he came a week later, missing orientation week. And I had the fling with ….” she answered as tears flowed from her eyes.

"Stop! Don't reveal your secret lover yet. But no longer a virgin anymore, you still never had sex with Josh?" asked the Magician

“I… I couldn't tell Josh. I hoped he would never find out. I do suck him and give him handjobs” she explained

“Stop. No need further explanations” said the Magician

“How about you? You've had sex with each other?" he asked. Both of them nodded.

"Were you two each other’s first?” he asked Susan and Ben.

Both of them shook their heads, but they both had a surprised look in their eyes at each other’s answer.

“Oh? Another surprise! So is your first lover on stage here with you?” asked the Magician.

Both of them nodded and looked at each other in shock and embarrassment. They then looked at their friends in suspicion.

“Interesting. Tell me your story Susan, but no names” asked the Magician.

“In the first few weeks of uni, I was still making friends. I was at a club function at a disco, and he stared at me with his lustful eyes. We ended up having a quickie in the bathroom” she answered, not being able to look at Ben.

“Heheh. How about you Ben? No names” he asked

“We were playing strip poker in our dorm to relieve steam during the exam period, and I lost. She commented how similar sized my cock was with her boyfriend's. One thing led to another and we ended up fucking” he answered, not being able to look at Susan.

“Oh, so your friend was already attached? Where was her other half?” the Magician asked.

“He still had a paper the next day, so he was studying” Ben answered.

“Intriguing. How about you?” the Magician asked Amanda and Bruce.

“Are you each other's first sexual experience?” the Magician asked.

Both Amanda and Bruce shook their heads.

"And your first lover is on stage here?" asked the Magician.

Both of them nodded and looked at each other in shock as well. There were too many revelations tonight.

“Amanda, tell us your story, no names” asked the Magician

“I met met him in the school gym sauna. After flirting a bit, we fucked in the sauna after everyone left” Amanda answered.

“How about your Bruce? Tell your story with no names” asked the Magician.

“All for of us guys are apartment mates and currently share an apartment. Our girlfriends frequently stay the night. On day, her boyfriend left for an early class and as I went for a shower and got back, I heard moaning from his room. As I entered the room to check, she was in his bed masturbating. She thought I had already left, and here I was in my towel, and she was naked in bed fingering herself. She looked at me in shock as my towel dropped. The next thing we knew, we were fucking. We promised not to tell him as it was a mistake” answered Bruce, not able to look at his girlfriend Amanda.

“Wow, your group is like a merry-go-round!” smiled the Magician.

“Ok then. Now since the Truth part of this game is over, lets get to the Dares”

The assistants brought out two double beds onto the stage, and placed them next to each other. Then they brought out a prop toilet as well as a prop sauna room. There was also a stack of towels nearby.

The whole group looked in shock, but was still unable to move.

“Before we have the first dare, Lily, strip Josh naked” ordered the Magician

She did so and stripped him naked, his 8 inch cock hung for all to see.

"As you are the only virgin here, it appears you will have to sit this game out Josh. You are allowed to masturbate though, but you cannot cum until I say so" the Magician ordered. 

“Ok, for our dares, I will get you to re-enact your first times, while the rest stand and watch” the Magician instructed. “Since you answered first Lily, you will re-enact your first sexual experience with your mysterious lover. ”

Josh’s eyes opened wide open, but he could not move or say anything.

Lily suddenly stumbled around apparently drunk as did Randy and they were supporting each other as they sat on the bed.

"Randy, you bastard!" thought Josh as he looked at both of them angrily. 

They looked at each other, and suddenly they started kissing passionately. Within moments, clothes were flying everywhere and they were both completely naked.

Lily had a gorgeous body and many in the audience were masturbating already. 

Randy’s 9 inch cock stood erect as Lily sat between his legs and gave him an energetic blowjob. Randy groped her breast with one hand as he held her hair in the other, then pulled her onto the bed and kissed her.

“I… I’ve never done this before” she whispered. The whole audience was so silent that it could be heard right at the back.

“Don’t worry, I’ll take good care of you” said Randy as he place the tip of his cock at her opening and shoved it in deep

Lily groaned as the 9 inch cock hit her cervix, then Randy started pumping.

Josh was already masturbating vigorously, his 8 inch cock pumping like mad as he watched his girlfriend being fucked by his best friend.

Randy was already fucking Lily like a machine, his hips going up and down like a piston. Before long, both Randy and Lily moaned loudly and he came deep into her pussy.

Josh continued masturbating, tears flowing from his eyes.

"Great. Now clean up and get dressed as we watch the next scene" the Magician said.

Both Randy and Lily got up and wiped themselves with the towels set aside for them. They cleaned up as if no one else was around and started getting dressed.

"Now lets see. Susan, please re-enact your first time with your mysterious lover" said the Magician.

Randy immediately took Susan by her hand and whispered in her ear. She smiled and they walked to the prop toilet and instantly she unzipped Randy’s still cock and and sucked him.

"Randy again! How very randy of you" exclaimed the Magician

Both Randy and Susan acted like they were in a bathroom stall and he hiked up her skirt and pushed her panties aside. Like a heat seeking missile, he shoved his cock into her and started fucking her doggie style.

"Feeling left out? How about you re-enact your first time with your secret lover?" said the Magician to Ben who was staring at Randy fucking his girlfriend Susan.

Suddenly, Lily walked to the bed and stripped to just her bra and panties and sat down as Ben stripped to his underwear.

"Lily again too! I guess Randy isn't the only player here" said the Magician.

Ben then walked to her and removed his underwear.

“Damn, I lost” he said as he revealed his flaccid 8 inch cock.

“Your dick looks so much like Josh’s” Lily said as she giggle cutely and flicked his penis with her pointing finger, making it swing left and right.

“Want to see if it’s really the same as Josh’s?” asked Ben jokingly.

“What.. what do you mean?” she asked him

“Well, what do you think I mean?” he asked her back.

“You.. you want to have sex with me?” she asked again as the mood of the conversation suddenly went from joking to serious.

Her hand went from flicking his cock to holding it.

“You… you are the most gorgeous person I’ve ever met. And here I am with my dick in your hand. What do you think?” he said.

They stared into each other’s eyes for a long while as Lily felt Ben’s cock grow erect in her hand.

Lily looked at his cock and slowly bent over and opened her mouth, engulfing it and sucking it with her eyes closed, as if tasting it and feeling to see if it was different from Josh’s

Josh's cock was rock hard as he continued masturbating and watching the scene while crying silently.

While re-enacting the scene, Lily was completely oblivious to Josh standing right next to her. In fact, if she reached out, she could hold Josh's cock too, but didn't.

Lily started taking off her bra and panties as she re-enacted her memory.

She stood up and grabbed his hand, then brought him to the bed as she lay him down on the bed and she got on top of him. She place his erect cock between her legs and looked at his eyes.

“I can’t believe I am doing this. Josh better not find out” she said as she sat down onto his cock and moaned sexily. 

She started rocking her hips and fucked him as he grabbed her gorgeous breasts.

In the meantime, Randy and Susan had already fucked in several positions in the prop toilet stall and Randy finally came inside Susan’s pussy.

“That’s a pretty energetic performance, both of you. You may clean up now" the Magician ordered and both Randy and Susan cleaned up and got dressed again.

Susan returned to her spot on stage and suddenly stared at Ben fucking Lily in shock. Josh still was masturbating and could not get satisfied.

On the other bed, Ben had just cum inside Lily’s pussy and were commanded to clean up and get dressed again.

"Angela. Its your turn with your mysterious lover!" said the Magician.

Angela stepped forwards and started stripping, as did Randy.

"Randy again!" exclaimed the Magician as both of them took a towel and walked to the prop sauna.

The belief was so real, both of them instantly started sweating as if in a real sauna.

Angela adjusted her towel as she smiled and sat next to him on the sauna.

“Hi, I’m Randy” he smiled as he extended his hand. “Angela” she smiled back.

They both started making small conversation as they sweat and untied their towels to only cover their relevant parts as they sat there.

“I wonder what time the gym closes” said Angela

“Don’t worry. The gym is 24 hours. However, it gets quiet after 10, which was probably an hour ago” he said.

“That’s a relief. I don’t want to be locked in here” she said.

“You don’t want to be locked in here with me?” Randy asked with a flirty smile.

“That’s not what I meant” she said as she stood up and retied her towel around her.

As she turned around, Randy was staring at her. Then suddenly, his hands went towards her and pulled her towel down.

She stood there, but didn’t flinch, revealing her naked body to him.

“You like?” she asked. He nodded and gulped as his cock got erect and a pitched a tent under the towel.

“Lets see whats under there” Angela said as she removed his towel and gasped at the sight of his cock.

“All this for me?” she said with glee as she started giving him a handjob. He in turn started groping her breasts.

She opened her mouth and started sucking him frantically before she got up and sat on him, impaling herself on his rock hard cock.

They both started moaning and fucking loudly.

Bruce looked at them impotently as Randy fucked his girlfriend Amanda.

“Don't get mad Bruce. It's your turn to re-enact your scene with your secret lover” the Magician instructed.

Bruce stepped out and started stripping as did Lily.

"Lily again!" exclaimed the crowd, caught up in the gossip. Josh continued masturbating in tears watching his girlfriend fuck his last best friend.

Lily lay in the bed nude and started masturbating as Bruce wore a towel around his waist and walked in on her masturbating.

“What… Bruce?” she said as he dropped his towel and stood naked in front of her.

His cock grew hard right in front of her, and she looked at him in amazement.

“What are you…” Lily said, but Bruce started playing with his cock while looking at her as if hypnotized.

She looked at him masturbating and her hand started automatically fingering herself again.

He moved closer to her and she looked at him, mesmerized by him pumping his cock.

He got close enough that the top of his cock was touching the knuckles of the fingers inside her pussy. 

"Wait... what ... what are you doing?" she asked in a whisper as her fingers exited her pussy and the tip of his cock touched the wet opening of her pussy. 

“Can I…. I’ve never had sex before” Bruce said while his started pumping his cock faster.

“Just.. just this once. I need a cock badly in me” Lily said.

Bruce pushed his hips forward and his cock automatically slid into her pussy that was already wet from her fingering.

She moaned together with him and he started pumping his cock into her.

At the same time, Josh never stopped masturbating his cock like a horny dog, watching yet another of his best friends fuck his lover.

In the fake sauna, Randy came inside Angela, and was resting inside her, still in doggie style.

“What an incredible performance Randy. Now both of you return to your positions” the Magician ordered.

As they walked to their positions, Bruce was cumming into Lily as Josh watched them both grunt with exhaustion.

As Bruce and Lily was ordered to stand in their original positions, but they didn't get dressed and stood naked after cleaning up.

The Magician looked at Josh “Did you enjoy the view of your girlfriend fucking your best friends, reliving their original encounter?” he asked as he watched Josh helplessly continue masturbating.

“No… yes.. I don’t know” he answered.

"You liked seeing Lily being fucked by other men, don’t you?” the Magician asked again.

“Yes. I like seeing Lily being fucked by other men” he admitted.

"Well excellent" he said as he brought Lily to stand in front of Josh.

"Remember that I told you that you will see my cock in action? Here it is" said the Magician as he bent Lily over in front of Josh and shoved his cock balls deep into her.

As he fucked Lily, he looked at Josh's face who was in agony.

He commanded all the other volunteers to strip again as he finished cumming inside Lily much to Josh's frustration as he was still masturbating.

However, after the Magician was done fucking Lily, Josh's cock started deflating again. He vigorously masturbated his flaccid cock but nothing was happening. 

"Poor Josh. I'll get some satisfaction for you" the Magician smiled as he got Lily to clean up his cum dripping out of her pussy.

He turned to Randy, who was standing nearby. 

“Randy! You've fucked them all. Who do you like best?” the Magician asked.

“I was in love with Lily. But after she dumped me, I went on a fucking spree” Randy answered

“And now? Are you still in love with Lily?” the Magician asked. 

“No. I’ve fallen for someone else” he answered.

“Susan or Angela?” asked the Magician

“No. I’ve fallen for someone, but she doesn’t even know I exist” he answered.

“Is she here in the audience tonight? Whats her name?” the Magician asked, still pumping.

“I don’t know if she came or not. Her name is Joey Kim” Randy answered.

“Is there a Joey Kim here?” asked the Magician

A girl hesitantly put up her hand. The whole audience was already by now completely mesmerized with the sex show.

“Come on up” instructed the Magician.

A pretty 5’6” Asian girl of Korean descent walked onto the stage.

The Magician snapped his fingers and Joey went into a trance, unable to move.

“Joey. Do you have a boyfriend here with you?” the Magician asked.

She shook her head.

“Are you a virgin?” he asked again.

She nodded and blushed.

“Ok Josh, stop masturbating and strip Joey here and bring her to the bed” the Magician instructed.

Josh obediently walked over to Joey and stripped her. She had gorgeous C cup breasts, similar to those of Lily, Susan and Angela. Then he brought her to the bed.

Randy looked appalled as the Magician instructed Josh to sit on the bed and Joey to suck him.

Joey started sucking Josh’s dick, but it was not getting hard at all. Her pretty mouth made erotic slurping sounds, but nothing was happening.

“I know what you need” smiled the Magician.

He instructed Randy to sit next to Josh and got Lily to suck Randy right next to Joey sucking Josh.

As Lily obediently sucked on Randy, getting him fully erect again, Josh’s cock sprang to life looking at Lily, and his 8 inch cock was fully erect in Joey’s mouth.

As that was happening, Lily and Josh kept looking at each other while Randy and Joey kept looking at each other.

The Magician brought the other pair to the other bed in similar positions and mixed up the partners, getting Angela to suck Ben’s cock while Susan sucked Bruce.

They were then commanded to fuck their partners missionary style, but were not allowed to cum.

Randy climbed onto Lily and fucked her as did Josh who fucked Joey. Joey moaned as he pierced her hymen and bled a little.

In the meantime, Ben started fucking Angela while Bruce fucked Susan.

The audience was silent as the moans and groans of the 4 pairs fucked in a rhythm.

Suddenly, the Magician reached out and pulled of Lily’s head.

She was shocked, but her head was still alive, while Randy was obediently fucking the headless body of Lily.

He placed his cock into Lily's mouth and invited his assistants onto the stage. 

His assistants came on stage and stated to take apart the fucking bodies. At first all the heads were pulled off and brought off stage, leaving the 8 headless bodies fucking like automatons.

Then the assistants removed the legs, leaving them fucking in an awkward position as the men could not thrust without their legs, and only used their hips.

Then their arms were removed, leaving the men lying down on the women’s torso, smashing their breasts.

Then the top torsos were separated from the hips and were passed out to the audience.

The women enjoyed touching the men’s muscled and chiseled bodies while the women’s breasts were happily fondled and groped by the men.

What were left were the hips of 8 people, joined in pairs by their genitalia.

Then the hips were separated and passed out to the audience.

The women’s pussies were fingered and even fucked as were their anuses.

The men’s erect penises entered the orifices of the audience members, not all of them female. Their anuses were fucked as well.

The night ended and the audience slowly left after returning all the body parts with all their orifices filled with cum. 

"4 gorgeous fleshbots and 4 good looking cockbots. This was a good night" the Magician thought to himself, finally cumming in Lily’s mouth.